The 10 Best Store Bought Alfredo Sauce in 2021

Chris Starks
Written by
Last update:

Store bought Alfredo sauce has come a long way and it’s amazing how many different brands and flavors are available at the supermarket. Before you know it, you’ll have a tough time deciding which one to buy. Looking back, it used to be that the choices were very limited with a few brands selling the same old stuff. I’m not sure when they started to sell all these amazing Alfredo flavors, but it sure is a welcome change.

I’ve put this list together of the 10 best store bought Alfredo sauces. Before you know it, you’ll have a tough time deciding which one to buy.

NameCategoryProduct
Knorr Alfredo Pasta Sauce MixBest OverallKnorr Alfredo Pasta Sauce Mix
Barilla Pasta SauceBudget PickBarilla Pasta Sauce
McCormick Pasta Sauce BlendUpgrade PickMcCormick Pasta Sauce Blend

1. Knorr Alfredo Pasta Sauce Mix

Our rating: 9 / 10

Knorr Alfredo Pasta Sauce Mix

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Convenient shelf-stable cans
  • Variety of flavors
  • Reasonable price

Cons:

  • Contributes to processed food
  • Low quality ingredients
  • Contains hydrogenated oils

As most of us will readily acknowledge, the convenience of canned pasta sauces is hard to deny. On the other hand, the use of aluminum cans does add a little bit of concern about the safety and health factors of these products.

Among the major players in the pasta sauce market, name of Lindvia products have become synonymous with quality and consistency.

Alfredo sauce is one of the two pasta sauces that form part of the Lindvia family. This product comes in a 16-ounce can, which is the standard size for all sauce products from this brand.

2. Simply Organic Alfredo Sauce Mix

Our rating: 8 / 10

Simply Organic Alfredo Sauce Mix

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Certified organic
  • Gluten-free(no gluten)
  • Kosher

Cons:

  • 30 calories per serving
  • Not suitable for vegans
  • Convenient packaging – need to scoop out and add water

Just because you’re a vegan doesn’t mean you can’t enjoy creamy Alfredo sauce made from scratch. The Simply Organic Alfredo Sauce Mix is a convenient way to cook up a gourmet meal for a special occasion or even a light weekday meal. Available in a pack of 12, this is one of the best store-bought Alfredo sauces we could find. Simply Organic is a brand of unbeatable quality and use the most advanced ingredients and strict USDA® organic standards.

Reviews for this product have a four-star average rating, and 97 percent of them are five stars. Customers love this sauce, saying it tastes just like the traditional Alfredo sauce. Some say that is the best-tasting Alfredo sauce mix they’ve tried, giving it a ‘fabulous taste’ rating.

3. Stonewall Kitchen Basil Alfredo Pasta Sauce

Our rating: 7 / 10

Stonewall Kitchen Basil Alfredo Pasta Sauce

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • 100% hand-made
  • Excellent taste and texture
  • Suitable for vegetarians and vegans

We came across this one at a local store and it looked too good to resist! We were inspired by the ingredients, specifically parmesan and basil, because our last venture into the Alfredo sauce world was a complete disaster.

So we thought we would give it another go and see where it takes us. Well, we must say that this sauce was one of the best, if not the best sauce we’ve ever tried, and believe us, we’ve tried hundreds.

So, you might be wondering why it’s so good? Well, that’s a good question. It’s not too thick, nor too watery it just has the right consistency.

4. Barilla Pasta Sauce

Our rating: 7 / 10

Barilla Pasta Sauce

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Creamy
  • Rich and tangy
  • Perfect consistency

Cons:

  • A bit salty
  • Some reviews say the recipe requires a bit of adjustment

How can you go wrong with a creamy Alfredo sauce? Barilla is known for making healthy but delicious pastas in our kitchen. And this Alfredo sauce is one of their bestselling products.

What’s so great about this pasta sauce is its rich flavor. It tastes just like homemade Alfredo sauce without the effort. Plus it’s the perfect consistency that won’t pour out of the container when you turn it upside down.

One thing you should keep in mind is that this is a pretty thick sauce, closer to the texture of a gravy than that of a runny dressing. So it’s not the best choice for pasta with small holes and much better for thicker noodles like fettuccine or angel hair.

5. The Only Original Alfredo Sauce

Our rating: 6 / 10

The Only Original Alfredo Sauce

Check Price on Amazon

This sauce has been in the market for a long time and is considered an original. It comes in a tin can and is ready to be heated to serve in 5 minutes. Roma is known for its quality food products and this one is no different. You can add this sauce to any recipe for a restaurant-quality dish. The product is shipped frozen and is imported from Italy.

This sauce has only 3% of calories from fat and tastes great. It is a healthy alternative for food to eat.

6. Delallo Sauce Creamy Alfredo

Our rating: 6 / 10

Delallo Sauce Creamy Alfredo

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • No MSG
  • Available in both 16 ounces and 24 ounces
  • No preservatives

Delallo has changed the game with their Alfredo sauce. We can’t get enough of this creamy Alfredo sauce that’s made with parmesan cheese, garlic, and sea salt.

This sauce does not have any preservatives. You get all the flavors of homemade sauce with this jar. And one jar can usually last for a long time. It’s great for pasta, pizza, or baking. It’s one of the best Alfredo sauces you can get in stores.

Alfredo sauce is often loaded with calories. Some of them are also packed with sugar, which makes them unhealthy to eat. But Delallo is different. This jar of creamy Alfredo sauce only contains 156 calories with only 17 grams of sugar. This is ideal for eating by the spoonful! There’s a reason why Delallo has numerous awards under their belt when it comes to this sauce. Truly, it’s one of the best Alfredo sauces out there.

7. McCormick Pasta Sauce Blend

Our rating: 5 / 10

McCormick Pasta Sauce Blend

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • The product is vegan friendly
  • This pasta sauce is dairy free
  • Gluten free
  • Non-GMO
  • All natural ingredients
  • One of the best pasta sauce you will find
  • Great value for money
  • It is absolutely delicious

Cons:

  • It is expensive
  • It will not taste like homemade Alfredo

This fettuccine dish will surely delight you. It has a creamy, garlic, and parmesan taste. The Heat N Serve Alfredo sauce from Knorr has the creamy rich texture of Alfredo sauce. It has been featured in several television shows and on top blogs and newspapers.

It is the perfect blend of parmesan, cream, and garlic that will bring a smile on your face.

This sauce does not contain palm oil which means that it is very healthy. It does not have any preservatives and uses a non-dairy alternative which means that it is a vegan-friendly sauce. This sauce is also free from gluten. It is a balanced nutrition since it has nutritional yeast, flax seed, chia seeds, and nutritional yeast. It also does not have any animal origin.

8. Mario Batali Alfredo Pasta Sauce

Our rating: 5 / 10

Mario Batali Alfredo Pasta Sauce

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Versatile – good for many dishes
  • Just-right saltiness
  • Good for chicken, pasta

Can´t go wrong with a classic recipe.

This recipe is modeled on the very classic Fettuccine Alfredo. The advantage of using this pasta sauce over the classic Alfredo recipe is that it comes premade and ready for you to use.

In appearance, it is a runny cream-colored sauce with specks of black pepper visible.

9. Bertolli Alfredo Sauce

Our rating: 5 / 10

Bertolli Alfredo Sauce

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Made with 12% real, natural parmesan cheese
  • Available in 3 sizes
  • You can make your favorite recipes with it

Cons:

  • Contain modified food starch
  • Contains soybean oil and whey

(Pack of 12)

Are you a fan of Italian food? Are you looking for an easy and delicious recipe? Look no further. The Bertolli Alfredo Sauce is a top pick because of its taste and versatility.

The 12% real, natural parmesan cheese is authentic and the perfect addition to your favorite pasta dish. It also comes in three sizes: one jar (3/15oz), two jars (6/15oz), and three jars (9/15oz).

10. Classico Asiago Romano Alfredo Sauce

Our rating: 3 / 10

Classico Asiago Romano Alfredo Sauce

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Made with Parmesan cheese, Asiago cheese, Romano cheese and cream
  • Creamy sauce
  • No preservatives added
  • Decent price for the amount

Cons:

  • Not the best taste
  • Contains milk, wheat, eggs, and soy
  • Can be too salty

This Classico Asiago Romano Alfredo Sauce is a classic when it comes to fettuccini Alfredo recipes.

The sauce has a distinct herby aroma with creamy Parmesan, Asiago, and Romano cheese. Although it is simple, this sauce is sure to please a crowd. You can simply heat it up in a saucepan over medium heat with a bit of milk, add some noodles and dinner is ready.

This is by far one of the most popular Alfredo sauce brands out there. The all-natural flavour is delicious, but some prefer a lighter Alfredo sauce. You may also like this in an alfredo salad recipe for a healthier option.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

What is the best store bought Alfredo sauce?

We spent quite a lot of time and energy gathering the best store-bought Alfredos we could find. Factoring in a variety of factors, we tasted test plenty of Alfredos from various brands. We took careful notes and analyzed our results to come up with a definitive list of the best store-bought Alfredo sauces. With this guide, we hope you can easily find the sauce that is just right for you.

Is there any good jarred Alfredo sauce?

You're going to need a decent jarred sauce for your pasta night. And for that excellent jarred marinara, you're going to need a good jarred Alfredo sauce as well (another good jarred red sauce option is Rao's Homemade Marinara Sauce).

Like with all jarred sauces and pastas, there will always be a slight inconsistency and it might not be what you'd expect. The flavors may vary slightly from one jar to another and the texture can be grainy, chalky, or gritty.

It's definitely not restaurant-quality, but it's hard to beat good Alfredo sauce. There's a reason why it's been a popular Italian staple for the last hundred or so years. It's creamy, rich, indulgent and so full of flavor, the slight inconsistencies will easily be forgiven.

How can I make store bought Alfredo sauce taste better?

There are many ways to improve the taste of store bought Alfredo sauce. The best way to add flavor to Alfredo Sauce is to add cheese. If you do not have Parmesan cheese available, you can grate some Asiago or Romano cheese on top for added flavor. You can also add salt and pepper, chopped garlic, or fresh or dried parsley on top.

What is the healthiest Alfredo sauce?

A common trend among many of the top purveyors of store-bought alfredo sauce is the use of whole milk or heavy cream. Of course, this will impact your calorie and fat intake. Another key point to consider when selecting your alfredo sauce is its carbohydrate content. Some brands have a lot of sugar or other ingredients that can raise your blood sugar significantly.

Not all store-bought alfredo sauce is bad for you, but of the brands we've highlighted, there are several that we believe to be relatively low in fat, calories, and carbs.

What makes a healthy alfredo sauce? When we assess the health of a pre-made pasta sauce, we take into account its fiber content. The average pasta sauce has about two grams of fiber per serving. The products listed below will contain at least this much fiber.

Conclusion

Alfredo sauce is a simple pasta sauce that is made from butter, cream, and cheese. It is very creamy and rich, since it is made from cheese, butter, and cream. Alfredo is heavenly when dolloped on a plate of spaghetti or linguine. It is an Italian sauce, and it is named after an Italian restauranteur who claimed to have invented the sauce. The restauranteur added it to his restaurant menu, and the sauce became very popular.

Here are the ten best store bought Alfredo sauces:

Our Recommendation

NameCategoryProduct
Knorr Alfredo Pasta Sauce MixBest OverallKnorr Alfredo Pasta Sauce Mix
Barilla Pasta SauceBudget PickBarilla Pasta Sauce
McCormick Pasta Sauce BlendUpgrade PickMcCormick Pasta Sauce Blend