The 5 Best Scotch Bonnet Pepper Substitutes

Chris Starks
Written by
Last update:

What is a scotch bonnet pepper?

The scotch bonnet pepper (also known as simply “bonnet pepper”) is a fruity, spicy pepper originating from Central America. It is one of the hottest peppers, measuring about 100,000 to 350,000 on the Scoville scale. It can pack a punch. It is closely related to the habanero pepper and can be up to 40 times hotter than a typical jalapeno pepper.

It is stringy and larger than most peppers. It’s one of the most common peppers used in Jamaican cuisine. Scotch Bonnet Peppers are named after “Scotsmen,” as the British first brought the pepper to Jamaica in the mid -19th century. The pepper is also referred to as a “Caribbean red pepper,” as it derives from the Caribbean island of Jamaica, where it is a significant ingredient in jerk sauce.

The Scotch Bonnet peppers’ flavor is fruity and sharp, with a lingering, pungent, and slightly sweet aftertaste. The extreme heat of Scotch Bonnet peppers is due to capsaicin production in quantity.

How healthy (or unhealthy) is it?

Scotch Bonnet peppers are the hottest chile peppers you can find from the Caribbean. You can find them in powdered and fresh forms in the grocery store. Like most peppers, they have many health benefits but can also cause severe illness when ingested in large quantities.

Some people think that Scotch Bonnets are the number one best chili pepper globally because they are such a versatile pepper; you can use them in any dish. They are also great to cook with because they penetrate the dish with a delicious flavor. They have brilliant red color, and you can use them to add vibrant color to your food as well.

The main component of the pepper that aids in health is a substance known as capsaicin. It is sometimes used for manufacturing medications such as circulatory stimulants, analgesics, and pepper spray. This substance is what causes the burning sensation.

Capsaicin is beneficial in warding off stomach, breast, and other cancers as it slows the growth of carcinogenic cells. The scotch bonnet pepper is also great to aid weight loss as it boosts the metabolism rate. It can also help in the treatment of cardiovascular disease. Not just that, this amazingly hot pepper acts as an anti-mucus agent and is a natural remedy for colds and sinusitis.

The roots of the bonnet pepper tree are suitable for treating asthma. You can soak bonnet pepper seeds in alcohol, making a perfect heat medicine to treat muscle and joint pain. Don't even leave the leaves of bonnet pepper. You can heat them and use them to treat insect bites effectively.

Nutritional Breakdown

Scotch Bonnet peppers are considered one of the hottest peppers on earth. High heat ratings on the Scoville scale offer several health benefits due to some tremendous nutritional content.

Compared to other peppers, they are also low in calories, which means they can add zing to your food without adding any calories.

Scotch bonnet peppers are an excellent source of phytochemicals, vitamin A, vitamin C (ascorbic acid), iron, vitamin B, carotenoids, niacin, riboflavin, dietary fiber, flavonoids, and magnesium.

What recipes use scotch bonnet peppers?

Scotch Bonnet peppers are some of the most flavorful peppers in the world. They are fiery hot, curved, and about the size of your palm. Because of their size, they tend to be cheaper than other peppers. Scotch Bonnets are also commonly used fresh in Caribbean, Jamaican, Latin American, and African cuisines and are a vital ingredient in various sauces.

If you can’t get your hands on them, you can also get similar recipes using other peppers. Here is a list of the five best Scotch bonnet pepper substitutes.

Why do we need scotch bonnet pepper substitutes?

Scotch bonnet pepper substitute is essential if you don’t have it at hand and wish to make a delicious Caribbean recipe to add zing to its sauces and stews.
There is a reason why it is unanimously agreed that Scotch Bonnet Pepper is the most popular & powerful of peppers and is also held in high esteem among the most commonly used pepper in Jamaican cuisine.

Unlike some peppers, which have similar names but different looks, tastes, textures, and shapes, Scotch Bonnets have a unique look and taste not identical to any other pepper.

But I’ve been told that you can also substitute it with habanero peppers whose seeds are not as hot as Scotch Bonnet pepper.

Habanero Pepper🌱

Some of you may be wondering if you can use habanero peppers as a substitute for scotch bonnets. Yes, you can, but you must be extremely careful while working with this pepper – primarily if you use it in a recipe that requires a long cooking time.

Also, regarding taste – habanero having the same level of heat and flavor as the scotch bonnet will give you all of the firepowers you need to spice up any dish. Hence, habanero makes an excellent substitute for those dishes that require the full potential of scotch bonnet peppers.

If you’re looking for a substitute that is relatively close in flavor, then habanero peppers are a good option. They are also an excellent alternative to scotch bonnet peppers if you want to cook authentic Jamaican cuisine.
They have about 100 times more Vitamin C than oranges, and they’re also rich in antioxidants, which makes them great for boosting your immune system over the winter months.

Jalapeno Pepper🌱

If you’re not a fan of too much heat, the jalapeno pepper will probably be your best bet. It’s hot but not overwhelming, and it’s the same size as a Scotch bonnet. The taste has a little bit of a kick, and the size of the pepper is manageable.

The pepper’s heat rating ranges from 3,500 to 8,000 Scoville heat units. A Scotch bonnet is rated 100,000 to 350,000 Scoville heat units to give you a reference point. So the jalapeno pepper has relatively less potency than the Scotch bonnet.

The jalapeno pepper needs to be cooked or canned or have its seeds and ribs removed before eating to prevent bitterness and acidity. It’s excellent as a condiment or mixed in with sauces.

Serrano pepper 🌱

The serrano pepper is a jalapeno with more heat, having 10,000 to 23,000 units on the Scoville heat scale. It’s one of the most common chili peppers in Mexico, known as “chile Gordo. 🌱 The name serrano means “mountain dweller, ” which speaks to where this chili pepper originated.

However, just because it’s referred to as a mountain chili pepper doesn’t mean that it doesn’t grow in other environments. It does just fine in hotter climates and proper irrigation. The serrano is both a hot and sweet pepper, but it’s generally used to give heat rather than flavor.

The serrano pepper is also a milder alternative to the Scotch bonnet pepper, one of the hottest peppers in the world and a staple of Caribbean cuisine. Scotch bonnets are readily available in West Indian grocery stores where the serrano pepper is also found. In mainland markets, however, the serrano pepper may be hard to find.

Rocotillo Pepper 🌱

Rocotillo pepper is described as a "goat head" pepper and is a variety of Scotch Bonnet. Rocotillos are considered to be more flavorful than scotch bonnets, but their flavor is similar but way too less hot than bonnet pepper having 1,500 – 2,500 SHU.

It's green at first but does turn red or orange when fully mature. Rocotillos can grow up to 2 inches in length and have a hole in the middle through which the spine sticks out. Some say Rocotillo peppers smell the most like scotch bonnets. They are a great substitute for scotch bonnets, especially if you're looking for a slightly pungent and flavorful pepper that's way less hot!

Thai Red Chili 🌱

These are by far among the hottest bonnet peppers. Thai peppers typically range from 50,000 to 100,000 Scoville Heat Units, quite close to bonnet pepper. The color is bright orange-red when dried, but they can be found fresh in Thai markets.

Thai chili peppers get their heat from their high concentration of a compound named capsaicin. You can substitute it for bonnet proper in nearly all recipes for a similar great taste and feel.

The Bottom Line

Scotch Bonnet Peppers are waxy orbs that come in different sizes and have a unique look that’s quite unlike any other pepper in the world. They are of Caribbean ancestry, and they are also popular in other regions of the world including Africa, and Brazil.

Scotch Bonnet Peppers are widely used in many Caribbean Recipes. Roasting the peppers is a popular way to make the skin easier to remove. They are also used in salsas and sauces to add flavor and heat to typical ingredients like tomatoes, onions, garlic, and cilantro.

Scotch Bonnet Peppers can be highly flavorful and highly spicy. They can become so hot that even experienced spicy food lovers have trouble consuming them, so you may also want to consider the scotch bonnet pepper substitute for less spicy dishes that you make.

There are some common substitutes for Scotch Bonnet Peppers, which we just discussed above.

Top Vegan Picks

If you can’t find scotch bonnet peppers, these are the best vegan substitutes that will fit the bill perfectly.

Red Habanero Pepper

Habanero peppers have a similar heat level as the scotch bonnet pepper, which makes them a good alternative. It is said that habanero peppers can even have a more robust flavor than scotch bonnet pepper when added as a substitute for bonnet pepper.

Red Cayenne Pepper

Cayenne peppers are sold in dried and powder forms. Cayenne pepper is commonly used to spice up dishes and is available in several colors, primarily red, orange, and yellow. Just make sure you choose the right one as there is also a green chili called cayenne pepper, but it is much milder than the red one. You can add this as a good vegan substitute for bonnet pepper, having a heat level of 30,000 – 50,000 Scoville Heat Units (SHU) on the Scoville Scale.

Chipotle Peppers

Chipotle peppers are smoked jalapeno peppers, so they are similar in terms of heat and flavor. If you need to spice up your meals and don't want to use bonnet pepper, you can easily find chipotle pepper at any major grocery store. You can use them anywhere you would use the scotch bonnet pepper.

Top Healthy Picks

If you want to replace Scotch Bonnet in your recipes, here's a list of the best healthy Scotch Bonnet pepper substitutes:

Thai Chili

Thai chili is used in Thai, Lao, and Vietnamese curries. It’s less hot than the scotch bonnet and a lot safer and healthy to ingest.

Serrano Chilli

Serrano chili is used in Mexican cuisine. It is slightly less hot than the scotch bonnet but with more complex aroma notes. You can safely substitute it for bonnet pepper in all recipes.

Cayenne Pepper

Cayenne is a deep red chili with a rich, sweet flavor and medium heat. It is a type of chili pepper mainly grown in the US. You will love the taste, but it is less hot and won't harm your digestive system it's you have a sensitive gut.

Top Convenient Picks

Scotch bonnets are among the most pungent peppers out there, so if you don’t have access to them, here are the convenient top picks.

Hot Red Chili Peppers

This is a blend of red chili peppers, and they tend to be milder and a bit sweeter than the Scotch Bonnet. One might add other ingredients to produce a range of spicy flavors. Hot red chili peppers are also very versatile and can be used in various dishes to replace bonnet pepper.

Tabasco Pepper Sauce

This is made from the Tabasco pepper, and it has a kick comparable to the Scotch bonnets. Cayenne pepper is also sweeter, but bear in mind that a lot of the sauce variants can be a bit bland, so you may need to add extra flavor from other sauces.

Habanero Pepper

The habanero is similar to a Scotch bonnet, but they tend to be a little milder, sweeter, and have less aftertaste. The habanero is a famous pepper for hot sauces and can replace the bonnet pepper in nearly any recipe.

Top Convincing Picks

Different chili pepper varieties are used in various ways to add hotness to all kinds of food. It’s not surprising to find out that the Scotch bonnet pepper variety is one of the hottest ones in the world.

This chili pepper, often called “Caribbean Red Hot Pepper” has set the world record for the spiciest pepper at an astounding 150,000 to 300,000 Scoville heat units.

The heat of the pepper can be dangerous if used wrongfully. So it’s great to know that there are a few hot pepper substitutes that can completely replace the real version if you’re interested in cooking but don’t want to live in water for at least a week.