The 10 Best Earl Grey Tea the Best Afternoon Tea

Chris Starks
Written by
Last update:

Afternoon tea can be a lovely way to settle down after a hard day's work. But how do you choose the best afternoon tea? Some salons are well known, but as a savvy drinker you'll want to ensure that you choose one that's special. This article narrows down the field and gives you ten of the best afternoon tea locations where you can enjoy tea and tasty treats.

NameCategoryProduct
Bigelow Earl Grey Black Tea BagsBest OverallBigelow Earl Grey Black Tea Bags
Taylors of Harrogate Earl GreyBudget PickTaylors of Harrogate Earl Grey
Teabox Classic Earl Grey Loose Leaf Black TeaUpgrade PickTeabox Classic Earl Grey Loose Leaf Black Tea

1. Bigelow Earl Grey Black Tea Bags

Our rating: 9 / 10

Bigelow Earl Grey Black Tea Bags

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Organic
  • Fair trade
  • Lack of GMO’s
  • Organic flavors
  • 20 bags per box
  • Eco-friendly packaging
  • Good caffeine content
  • Discount for bulk orders

Cons:

  • The flavor seems to be inconsistent from batch to batch
  • Contains a higher amount of EGCG than other brands
  • Some tea users complain about the lack of depth and taste of the flavor
  • Caffeine content can vary from tea to tea more than some other varieties of tea

Bigelow tea was established in 1945 and has been an industry staple for over seven decades. They’re known for their quality teas, friendly customer service provided through social media, and a quality control process that only includes organic and fair trade ingredients.

Bigelow’s Earl Grey comes in certified organic flavorings, which means everything from the tea leaves to the ethically-harvested herbs and the flavorings are involved. This tea contains higher amounts of EGCG and the other antioxidants than other brands. They’re certified by the Fair Trade Federation as well.

2. Harney & Sons Earl Grey Supreme

Our rating: 9 / 10

Harney & Sons Earl Grey Supreme

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Tea in a cup
  • Organic ingredients
  • Resealable package
  • Five different flavors
  • Affordable price

Cons:

  • The black tea is not high quality
  • Not very authentic

Same tea, better tea. Earl grey is basically a black tea with added bergamot citrus for flavor plus a splash of cream or milk. Harney & Sons Earl Grey Supreme is popular because of its classic flavor with a unique orange touch that makes Earl Grey Supreme an exceptional blend.

In addition, the tea comes with 20 sachets to offer you more than one cup a day. It’s convenient for when you’re going on a trip or if you have a long day ahead of you.

A cup of Earl Grey Supreme is ideal for a lazy Sunday afternoon or to go with your afternoon snack. Iced, with lemon and sugar, or taken with a slice of cake, can’t you just imagine how refreshing this tea would be after a stressful day?

3. Ahmad Tea Earl Grey Aromatic Loose Tea

Our rating: 9 / 10

Ahmad Tea Earl Grey Aromatic Loose Tea

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Great caddy design
  • High quality loose leaf tea
  • Fresh smell and taste of the leaves
  • Discounted tea caddy

Cons:

  • Not easily accessible
  • Loose tea makes it difficult to measure amount

(100 Grams)

Tea caddies make the perfect gift for all tea enthusiasts, and this one from Ahmad is no exception. It features the well-known Earl Grey flavor that is one of the most popular during afternoon tea. Made from the finest leaf tea from Ceylon, Ahmad Tea is a high-quality loose leaf tea.

Tea enthusiasts can also enjoy the robust flavor of Earl Grey flavored with bergamot oil, an amazing aroma that perfectly captures the taste of the Earl Grey. Made from fresh whole leaf tea, this is a light and refreshing tea caddy, which turns the ritual of drinking tea into something even more enjoyable. Say goodbye to those tea bags – loose leaf tea is here to stay.

4. Stash Tea Organic Earl Grey Tea 100 Count Tea Bags in Foil

Our rating: 8 / 10

Stash Tea Organic Earl Grey Tea 100 Count Tea Bags in Foil

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Great flavor
  • Affordable price
  • Organic product
  • All the health benefits from tea

England's Finest Tea.

In search of the best tasting Earl Grey tea brands? If so, the Stash Tea: Organic Earl Grey Earl Grey is a tasty black tea. It is made from top grade Ceylon white tea, with roasted bergamot flavor. This blend is one of the best Earl Grey tea blends on the market today. It is also available in tea bags and loose leaf. With the tea bags you only need to place 1 bag per cup of hot or iced water. Sip, but don’t forget to add a little bit of milk to create a delicious blend.

Organic Stash Tea is the one of the best Earl Grey teas you can buy as well as one of the most popular. It has no fillers or additives and is certified USDA Organic. This tea can be used as a base to create a delicious beverage. With a whole leaf brewing, the aroma and flavor is truly amazing.

5. Taylors of Harrogate Earl Grey

Our rating: 8 / 10

Taylors of Harrogate Earl Grey

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • British made
  • Ideal for afternoon tea
  • Refreshing and invigorating
  • Full of bergamot flavor
  • Black tea is considered as one of the healthiest tea varieties
  • Can be served both hot and cold
  • Has a very pleasing aroma
  • Tastes great when mixed with other black teas
  • Great as an iced tea

There are 50 teabags in a box, and it’s part of the Taylors of Harrogate range. Taylors is one of the best-known manufacturers of tea in the UK, so you know you’re getting quality tea.

The teabags are individually wrapped, which helps them stay fresh. This makes them ideal for afternoon tea or if you’re giving the tea as a gift.

The bags are large enough and easy to use. They also make it easy to get out every single drop of tea leaves, even if you leave them in for a bit too long.

6. Numi Organic Tea Aged Earl Grey

Our rating: 8 / 10

Numi Organic Tea Aged Earl Grey

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Organic tea
  • Mild tasting
  • Very affordable
  • No added flavor or sugar
  • Strong presentation overall
  • Classic tasting
  • Lovely appearance
  • Low caffeine
  • Affordable, if bought in bulk
  • Excellent tea for after supper

Cons:

  • Packaging can be low quality
  • A little weak

This is another version of the Numi Organic Tea Aged Earl Grey. It is the 18 count of tea bags, in a box. It is the same tea, as the other one review above, but in a box. It also has the same amount of caffeine, but contains a slightly lower amount of tea bags.

It is a classic tea, and if you like Earl Grey, you will love this tea. The box is large, and you can see in the picture that it is beautiful, and makes a lovely presentation. Although it is not a fancy tea set itself, it is still worth having for a nice afternoon or nighttime tea.

7. VAHDAM, Earl Grey Tea Leaves

Our rating: 8 / 10

VAHDAM, Earl Grey Tea Leaves

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • USDA Organic
  • 100% Natural Ingredients
  • Exceptional Caffeine Free, Anti Aging, Antioxidant properties
  • Contains Essential Oils and Vitamins
  • Organic Fair Trade
  • Lightly Sweet, not overpowering with sweeteners
  • Natural source of Antioxidants
  • GMO-Free, Gluten Free, Vegan, and Kosher
  • Zero Calories
  • Great for Weight Loss Diets

Cons:

  • No tea bags or boxes.
  • Ever asked why your Earl Grey tea smells and tastes like bergamot? Well, that’s because of the bergamot oil.
  • Bergamot oil is an aromatic citrus fruit that are used to flavor Earl Grey tea for that zesty citrusy aroma and taste.
  • Although its medium-sized to large in size and has an ovular shape, it looks like an orange like in shape.
  • It has yellow-green edible flesh with a thick skin, which makes it look like an orange as well.

(1 bag)

8. Golden Moon Tea

Our rating: 8 / 10

Golden Moon Tea

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Cheaper than many other brands of tea
  • Packed with flavor, it will give you the energy you need
  • Easy to find on most sites

Cons:

  • Not well liked by people who like to keep things simple
  • Very strong taste

Golden Moon Tea has produced one of the world’s best Earl Grey teas. The loose-leaf tea included with this package has a very strong taste and aroma. There isn’t anything simple about it … you have to really love intense flavors to appreciate the way this tea tastes.

This tea is perfect for anyone who has an energy deficiency because of its ability to energize the body without caffeine. It’s also a great tea for anyone who would like to use a bolder tea as a mixer … this tea is so strong that it can stand up to almost any other kind of tea.

This isn’t a tea to waste when it comes to price. You will disappoint yourself if you only take a sniff of this tea and then toss it out. You need to spend some time letting this tea brew and breathe and you will be rewarded with a super-strong tea that has a wonderful aroma.

9. Mighty Leaf Black Tea

Our rating: 8 / 10

Mighty Leaf Black Tea

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Organic
  • Delicious-tasting cups of tea
  • High quality
  • Caffeine-free

Awarded with the Best Tea of the Year Award for three years running, this black tea blend will definitely have you reaching for more. It has a distinct bergamot flavor with light citrus tones of orange.

This organic Earl Grey comes in 15 pieces of individually wrapped tea bags. It has a caffeine-free blend comprised of tree-grown and natural black tea leaves, and is made with natural and organic ingredients.

There are 10 tags with 3 tins of tea each. The tin itself is airtight to help preserve the crisp quality of the tea leaves.

10. Teabox Classic Earl Grey Loose Leaf Black Tea

Our rating: 5 / 10

Teabox Classic Earl Grey Loose Leaf Black Tea

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Uses authentic and pure Darjeeling tea from the Indian Himalayas
  • An ideal tea for tea beginners
  • Uses a special infusion brewing method
  • Exceeds the safety regulations of the industry
  • Individually wrapped for easy storage and convenience
  • Rich flavour which every tea lover will enjoy

Cons:

  • Mandatory brewing instructions aren’t applicable for all tea makers and methods
  • Some people have complained about the quality of this product

If you’re a tea lover who’s looking for the best afternoon tea, then Teabox’s Classic Earl Grey Black Tea could be a great choice.

This tea has been made from the finest quality tea leaves with a base of pure bergamot oil infused to deliver a rich taste. On top of that, this tea has been made from Mohan’s family plantation in Darjeeling, India. This particular batch is from the Maharani Tea Garden, one of the most famous regions from where this tea originates.

The bergamot oil is infused in the tea leaves. This gives it a pungent taste with an ideal citrus aroma and isn’t too bitter like some Earl Grey teas.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

Which brand of Earl GREY tea is the best?

Looking to experience an afternoon tea that's wildly different from the kind of tea you drink at home? You'll want an Earl Grey tea with BIG BOLD FLAVOR. You're not looking for a tea that tastes mild or delicate. Instead, you'll want a tea that packs a punch and has a bold taste.

The tea should be complex, with distinct citrus notes. You want to taste bergamot, which is a citrus fruit with a very distinct taste. If the tea tastes thin, watery, or weak, leave it for another brand.

You should also look for an Earl Grey tea bag that's not too bitter. The best Earl Grey tea can be purchased online, since you may not find them in grocery stores.

What flavor goes well with Earl GREY tea?

In our book, the most popular flavor is chocolate. It pairs beautifully with tea in general, but it truly is heavenly when added to Earl Grey. Lavender is another very popular flavor. Earl Grey is a great way to try a floral tea if you're not already a fan of this taste.

Since Earl Grey is a black tea, it pairs well with virtually any flavor. After all, black and green teas are both blended with regular tea leaves. If you're looking for a classic Earl Grey, you should add a slice of lemon to the cup. We also recommend adding a bit of sugar to balance out the bitterness.

What are the best Earl GREY tea bags?

Choosing the best tea bags isn’t just about how much you like a particular tea. This is because all teas are subjective and personal. It’s not a matter of one tea being better than another, just a matter of your tastes and preferences. The right tea is the one that puts a smile on your face and boosts your mood. If you aren’t happy, then it doesn’t matter how tasty your tea is.

Which Earl GREY tea has real bergamot?

The best tea for this purpose is usually a blend with bergamot and all varieties such as the bergamot, lavender and earl grey are best is because they are the black tea base, rather than an oolong base. I would avoid fruity flavored teas that often have floral elements that I prefer to pair with white teas. I recognize that it depends on your personal preference as some people like floral earls: I just encourage you to try other variants as I am a bit passionate about this topic!

Conclusion

So when it comes to the best Earl Grey tea, you’d think that all Earl Grey teas are created equal, but for some they are very different. For example, you’ve probably purchased many of the different types of Earl Grey that offer the same flavor. You might conclude that they are all the same. Is that really the case? The answer is no.

Our Recommendation

NameCategoryProduct
Bigelow Earl Grey Black Tea BagsBest OverallBigelow Earl Grey Black Tea Bags
Taylors of Harrogate Earl GreyBudget PickTaylors of Harrogate Earl Grey
Teabox Classic Earl Grey Loose Leaf Black TeaUpgrade PickTeabox Classic Earl Grey Loose Leaf Black Tea