The Best Canned Oysters for A Quick Oyster Stew

Chris Starks
Written by
Last update:

Oysters are the most loved seafoods because of their unique taste profile and nutritional value.

Are you craving oyster stew but have no fresh oysters available? You can grab canned oysters off the shelf and make a quick and delicious stew without burning a hole in your pocket. If it is difficult to source fresh oysters, or you live far from the coast, then canned oysters are the best alternative. You can also use canned smoked oysters as topping for crackers.

To warm smoked oysters, just open the tin’s seal and warm the tin up in the oven before serving. You can find a plethora of different canned oyster options. Canned oysters are cheaper yet guaranteed safe for consumption. Canned oysters are stored in oil or water with preservatives. They are full of antioxidants that reduce lipoprotein (bad cholesterol).

Canned oysters can be fresh or smoked. It means they are cooked and edible right out of the can. The ones that say “boiled” are not smoked, which means they retain more of the original oyster flavor.

You can store unopened canned oysters for up to a year from purchase (check that expiration date). Once opened, ensure to refrigerate any unused portion and consume within two days.

NameCategoryProduct
Crown Prince Whole Boiled OystersBest OverallCrown Prince Whole Boiled Oysters
Roland OystersBudget PickRoland Oysters
Reese Medium Smoked OystersUpgrade PickReese Medium Smoked Oysters

1. Crown Prince Whole Boiled Oysters

Our rating: 8 / 10

Crown Prince Whole Boiled Oysters

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Whole Oysters, Water, Salt
  • Sustainably grown and harvested Oysters
  • Recyclable can
  • Non-GMO
  • Boiled Oysters have a clear, clean appearance
  • 6,325 mg Omega-3 per serving

Cons:

  • Some good, some bad
  • Mushy
  • Some complain about oysters being flavorless and dry

Crown Prince Whole Boiled Oysters are probably the most sold oysters in the US. These are most likely one of the reasons why most Americans love oysters.

Crown Prince cans claim to provide delicious oysters designed for cooking. These are salt-cured and have just the right amount of salt to get the flavor right. It's also packed with other stuff to give you a good meal in 10 minutes.

These oyesters in brine come packed in an 8-ounce can. Just use it to make a perfect oyster stew or as a topping for your favorite soup or salad.

2. Reese Medium Smoked Oysters

Our rating: 8 / 10

Reese Medium Smoked Oysters

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Cherrywood smoked in cottonseed oil
  • Rich source of Omega-3
  • Easy to open can
  • Delicious smoked taste

Cons:

  • It may be lacking in flavor and texture
  • Can be highly smoky for some people
  • Dried-out taste

Oysters in a can are not only an excellent idea for practicality's sake but also to satisfy your love for oysters. Reese is the medium smoked oyster, and the taste is very similar to that of the famous Chesapeake Bay Oysters: creamy with a rich smoky flavor.

These are good oysters, and you will love them, the only problem is the size, they are smaller than usual. The best way to use these steamed oysters is to pair them with steamed greens.

3. Roland Oysters

Our rating: 8 / 10

Roland Oysters

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Wild-caught
  • Harvested from Pacific
  • Cured by Cherrywood smoke
  • Ready to serve
  • Smokey, but not overpowering
  • Great for soups, stews, and pasta dishes
  • Mild briny flavor and firm texture

Cons:

  • Mushy
  • No regularity in size
  • Mediocre taste

The company has been around for almost 100 years and has a solid reputation for the quality of its canned oysters. These small smoked oysters are the perfect companion to an outdoor stew or seafood pasta dish.

The size is a bit smaller than the standard can. These oysters have that famous smoky flavor that some people might not like. The smoke processing enhances the taste, and you just can’t help yourself if you’re the kind of person who enjoys a good smoke.

4. MW Polar Seafood

Our rating: 7 / 10

MW Polar Seafood

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Pack of twelve 8-ounce cans
  • All-natural whole boiled oysters
  • Free of heavy metals and biotoxins

Cons:

  • The taste and texture isn't excellent
  • Chewy and tasteless

Oysters are a luxurious delicacy, and these are the best-canned oysters available right now. They come in a pack of twelve. Each cauliflower-sized can weighs eight ounces and is equivalent to about eight oysters. We discovered these oysters to be incredibly delicious and easy to open.

They are also 100% natural and can be eaten straight from the can. There are no dyes, fillers, or preservatives added. They are a safe, nutritionally rich, and delicious addition to your everyday diet.

5. Crown Prince Natural Whole Boiled Oysters

Our rating: 7 / 10

Crown Prince Natural Whole Boiled Oysters

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Sustainably raised and harvested in South Korea
  • Non-GMO Project Verified Product
  • Pack of twelve 8-ounce cans
  • 6,325 mg omega-3 per serving

Cons:

  • Contain shell fragments
  • The product may be mushy

Canned oysters are one of the easiest and most economical ways to get the most out of a spectacular oyster stew. Whole oysters tend to be exceptional in texture and are a great way to introduce this delicacy to children.

Crown Prince brand oysters are packed in 8 ounces cans available at a very reasonable price for seafood. They are tasty and fresh and loaded with a taste that will power you through a good workday.

These giants have a protein-packed meaty texture and can be a good source of iron and zinc, and other essential minerals for a healthy body.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

What are the best canned oysters?

The best-canned Oysters are found in big cans. The big cans are the best value, and you get more oysters for your money. That's why it makes sense to always look for the larger cans; they are the best value.

There is no reason to buy inferior canned oysters like "No Name" brands. Usually, those are sold in smaller cans or packages and are cheaper because they are made from smaller oysters and generally are not as fresh.

How long do you cook canned oysters?

There are no hard and fast rules about how long you should cook oysters. However, my recommendation is to cook until the oyster's edges are curled. 45 mins is a good time for baking oysters.

What goes good with oyster stew?

Here are a few things that go great with oysters in a rich cream based sauce:

  • Green salad, dressed up with fragrant olive oil, garlic, and a squeeze of lemon
  • A French baguette (especially for dipping)
  • Grilled corn on the cob
  • Brown rice
  • Sautéed garlic or onions
  • A glass of wine

What can I do with canned boiled oysters?

There are so many things that you can do with canned boiled oysters. The first thing that comes to mind is actually making a soups. That's right, you can make oyster stew with canned oysters.

The second thing that comes to mind is as an appetizer for the Thanksgiving and Christmas holiday. Third, they are perfect for parties, get-togethers, and family events. And fourth, they are great to keep in the pantry or your emergency food stockpile.

Conclusion

Canned oysters make an excellent addition to your stir-fry or soup. They are nutrient-dense, easy to store and cook and make a tasty, fragrant oyster stew.
Whether you enjoy a subtle briny flavor or a stronger pickled flavor, canned oysters share a slightly fishy flavor that creates a fantastic complimentary taste when paired with the right ingredients. So add a unique flavor to your dish by adding canned oysters to your food.

Our Recommendation

NameCategoryProduct
Crown Prince Whole Boiled OystersBest OverallCrown Prince Whole Boiled Oysters
Roland OystersBudget PickRoland Oysters
Reese Medium Smoked OystersUpgrade PickReese Medium Smoked Oysters