The 10 Best Cake Pop Makers in 2022

Chris Starks
Written by
Last update:

Pulled out of our Best Baby Products, we’ve put together a selection of the 10 Best Cake Pop Makers on the market. Sorting through the different features that these products have was a little tricky as they all looked great, but learning about their best features will give you a better idea of which product is right for you.

NameCategoryProduct
Babycakes CC-12 Full Size Cupcake MakerBest OverallBabycakes CC-12 Full Size Cupcake Maker
Nordic Ware Donut Hole and Cake Pop PanBudget PickNordic Ware Donut Hole and Cake Pop Pan
Babycakes Pop Maker: CP-94LVUpgrade PickBabycakes Pop Maker: CP-94LV

1. Babycakes CC-12 Full Size Cupcake Maker

Our rating: 9 / 10

Babycakes CC-12 Full Size Cupcake Maker

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Great durability and quality
  • Compact and portable, easy to store in a kitchen cabinet
  • Stylish pink color
  • Makes 12 cake pops at a time
  • 8-hour timer
  • Easy cleanup with dishwasher
  • Can be used as a mini slow cooker, a 5-quart slow cooker, and in the oven up to 400F
  • Removable parts are dishwasher safe
  • Cleaning brush for easy cake pop removing
  • Non-stick baking surface

Cons:

  • No built-in temperature gauge
  • Capacity reverts to six at the highest setting
  • Directions are a bit difficult to follow

If you’re looking for a great-quality cake pop maker to make delicious homemade snacks, look no further. The Babycakes CC-12 Cupcake Maker makes 12 cake pops at a time and is equipped with a non-stick baking surface for easy cleanup.

Its compact design is a perfect addition to any kitchen, and the stylish pink color makes it a cute addition to a girl’s birthday party.

2. Babycakes Pop Maker: CP-94LV

Our rating: 7 / 10

Babycakes Pop Maker: CP-94LV

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Cake pop making made easy
  • Dishwasher safe and BPA free
  • Makes cake pops in three different sizes
  • Versatile; can be used to make many other desserts
  • Comes with 24 free recipes

Cons:

  • Poor quality control – some units have damaged electrical components
  • A bit overpriced

The Babycakes Pop Maker is a fantastic kitchen tool designed for everyone, from beginners to veterans in the cake pops gamut.

The Babycakes Pop Maker is made for versatility and can be used to make cake, biscuit, sweet or savory balls in different sizes.

You can also use it to cook egg rolls, stir fry noodles, quick breads, and even pies and muffins. And it’s dishwasher safe, made from BPA free materials and it’s manufactured and assembled in the US.

3. Brentwood Cake Pop Maker Non-Stick

Our rating: 7 / 10

Brentwood Cake Pop Maker Non-Stick

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Includes a non-stick coating for easy cleanup
  • Great for first time users and advanced ones alike
  • Can cook up to 80-pops at a time
  • The price is right
  • The recipe book- helpful for new users
  • Good quality recipes
  • Easy to use

Cons:

  • The timer only provides a 5-minute window, with no graduations or other indicators
  • Not for raw foods

One of the newer cake pop makers of the bunch, this Brentwood model delivers something a little different to the traditional cake pop maker in that it boasts an impressive 80-pops capacity at a time, along with a non-stick coating that makes cleanup simple.

What’s great about the Brentwood device is that you can cook every kind of cake pie in it: USCAKE®, Dum Dums/cake pops, cake slices, pie pops, pies rolls, and even mini mug cake. This means that no matter what kind of cake pops you want to create, this kitchen gadget can handle it. There’s also a built-in tray divider (with removable racks) that lets you prepare multiple kinds of cake pop at once. This not only saves you time, but it also saves on endless counterspace while you cook.

4. Nordic Ware Donut Hole and Cake Pop Pan

Our rating: 7 / 10

Nordic Ware Donut Hole and Cake Pop Pan

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Well-made and durable
  • Comes with two silicone mold pans
  • Cakes pop out easily
  • Makes uniform shaped cake pops
  • Easy to clean
  • Durable non-stick coating
  • Leaf-sprung design for even baking

Cons:

  • Feels cheaply made
  • Has a few reports that cakes pop out too easily

Are you a fan of cute and tasty mini cakes? Well, if you are, then you are going to absolutely love this donut holder and cake pop maker.

It is a handy two-piece baking pan that will make the fluffiest, lightest, and cutest cake pops you have ever seen – and baked!

One of the first things you will notice as you open up the packaging is a thoughtful label indicating how to use this tool. Very straightforward and helpful for anyone who is a complete novice.

5. Babycakes Mini Cake Pop Maker

Our rating: 6 / 10

Babycakes Mini Cake Pop Maker

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Manufactured by Babycakes
  • Hand mixer required, which comes with cake pop maker
  • Ultimate gift for kids
  • Becoming a hot trend on Twitter, Instagram, and Facebook

If you want to keep up with the hottest trend in the internet, you should get yourself a Babycakes Mini Cake Pop Maker.

This brightly colored machine is guaranteed to bring joy to any household’s party, and the best part is that it comes with an in-built hand mixer, so you don’t need any other devices.

Once you have made your cake balls, you only have to push down the dome and your Popsicle-like desserts are ready. On top of that, the cake pop maker is super easy to clean.

6. Babycakes Multi-Treat Baker

Our rating: 6 / 10

Babycakes Multi-Treat Baker

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • BPA-free cake pops
  • Heat Resistant handles
  • Cake pop recipe included
  • Cake pops can be frozen

The Babycakes mult-treat maker is one of the best sellers on Amazon. It comes in 6 colors and provides a great way to easily prepare perfect cake pops for the whole family.

The Babycakes cake pop maker is not the smallest, but that doesn’t make it any less versatile. It comes with an adjustable thermostat, so you can easily make both cake pops and cookies. It’s also features handles that are heat resistant, which allow you to fill the pop-cake maker up while it’s on. It’s designed with non-stick coatings so you can easily remove the pop-cake maker when releasing them from the mold.

The Babycakes pop-cake maker comes with a recipe on how to prepare your first cake pops and it’s also easy to follow. The recipe also includes a hack on how to make sure your cake pops taste as good as they can. The Babycakes pop-cake maker also allows you to bake your recipe in the oven, however, the cooking time will vary since it uses different temperatures.

7. VonShef 12 Cake Pop Maker Machine Set Includes Sticks & Stand

Our rating: 6 / 10

VonShef 12 Cake Pop Maker Machine Set Includes Sticks & Stand

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Comes with a digital timer; no need to hover a look at the clock every few minutes hoping the pop will be ready on time
  • Portable, making it ideal for parties, picnics, and backyard barbeques
  • Easy to setup
  • Easy to wash
  • Ideal for kids

Cons:

  • Doesn’t come with a recipe book
  • The stand is very light, and is not very sturdy

We were sure our pick for Cake Pop Makers is a winner. With a simple design and an affordable price, it is easy to use and clean.

As you can see from the title, this great pops maker comes with everything you need to make your own tasty pops at home. The set comes with a cake pop maker, 3 cupcake moulds, 2 sticks, and a manual with a few recipes.

You can use any recipe you like or are familiar with; no need to stick to the ones provided in the manual. The maker is designed to cook cake pops in about 6 minutes and the manual specifies that baby cakes take about 3 minutes to cook.

8. Disney Cake Pop Maker

Our rating: 6 / 10

Disney Cake Pop Maker

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • BPA free
  • Various designs available
  • Easy to use and clean
  • Holds 8 standard size or 12 minis
  • Two recipe books included
  • Has nonstick trays

Cons:

  • Can’t use metal tools
  • Plastic trays stick to some mixtures

What makes this a top pick in the field of cake pop makers is the way it makes use of tried and tested methods with some much-needed improvements, like nonstick trays.

The trays slide out for ease of use, are coated with nonstick surface so your treats won’t end up stuck to them. The 8 x 3 inch or 12 x 2” bases make it easy to bake many standard size or minis at a go. It has a 220-watt motor. You can keep your batter warm for up to 3 hours. So basically, you can keep a batch going all day long.

There’s a recipe book included; you also get a second recipe book online. 22 tips & tricks round out the set. Pretty useful.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

What is the best cake pop maker?

If you are looking to buy a cake pop maker, we recommend you get the BabyCakes Original Pop Maker because it is one of the most popular models on the market. With thousands of positive customer reviews, it is an established leader and certainly an excellent choice for those looking to buy a cake pop maker.

What is a cake pop maker?

Flavored cake bites (or cake pops) are a popular treat in bakeries and coffee shops. Making a cake pop at home has long been a challenge that many ambitious bakers couldn't manage. The practice required baking a cake and then blending the cake bits to make a crumb that resembles a powder. Next, you'd mold the flour mixture into delicious cake balls and finally stick the balls on a stick.

These events seemed incredibly difficult and time consuming, but the cake pop maker allows all of these steps to happen in one device, in a manner of minutes. The newest varieties even specialize in chocolate.

How far in advance should you make cake pops?

It's all up to you! Baking the cake and letting it cool completely in the pan is all you need to do in advance. When ready to start icing or decorating, simply take the pan out of the refrigerator, remove the cake from the pan with a knife, and cut the cake into ½-inch slices. The cake will harden right away and can be kept in the freezer for several days to make it easier to cut. The only downside to this method is that you'll end up with some icing gaps in your cake pops. But I have found the gaps disappear when the icing covers the entire cake slice.

There are kits available that already contain rolled cake, ready for dipping; these are very convenient, but I've found that a homemade cake worked just as well when making cake pops.

How much should I charge for a dozen cake pops?

Conclusion

There are quite a few cake pop makers on the market and they all vary in price, ease of use, reliability, and value for the money.

In this post, we’ve reviewed our Top 10 cake pop makers. We indicate the strongest selling points for each item and give you the pros and cons of each item so that you can make an informed decision. This will give you confidence that you’ll buy the right cake pop maker for you.

Our Recommendation

NameCategoryProduct
Babycakes CC-12 Full Size Cupcake MakerBest OverallBabycakes CC-12 Full Size Cupcake Maker
Nordic Ware Donut Hole and Cake Pop PanBudget PickNordic Ware Donut Hole and Cake Pop Pan
Babycakes Pop Maker: CP-94LVUpgrade PickBabycakes Pop Maker: CP-94LV